Don’t play Evony

Spam, a tin of

Evony breasts advert

Evony is a new, free, browser MMO. And their marketing consists of spamming up the internet like crazy. This blog is receiving a huge number of spam “comments” from them. Fortunately Akismet anti spam puts them automatically into the bin. Here are some of the email addresses they are using for this spam:

tsenseless.evony.com/bx8s07@naplesnews.net

tsenseless.evony.com/4cdtyg0fv@hotmail.com

tsenseless.evony.com/m36fqptkw2@naplesnews.net

tsenseless.evony.com/sfhwrv@live.com

tsenseless.evony.com/fhgpzdbk80@naplesnews.net

tsenseless.evony.com/w85@darkhorsefan.net

tsenseless.evony.com/xycw5vd@student.com

tsenseless.evony.com/ndh4pr1@bolt.com

tsenseless.evony.com/f3ypkg6@postmark.net

tsenseless.evony.com/ftcs@usa.com

tsenseless.evony.com/6n8ck@naplesnews.net

tsenseless.evony.com/rjd@email.com

And so on. They are doing this from the IP address 63.223.110.211

Whois Record

OrgName:    Beyond The Network America, Inc.
OrgID:      BNA-42
Address:    450 Springpark PL
Address:    Suite 100
City:       Herdon
StateProv:  VA
PostalCode: 20170
Country:    US

NetRange:   63.216.0.0 - 63.223.255.255
CIDR:       63.216.0.0/13
NetName:    BTN-CIDR5
NetHandle:  NET-63-216-0-0-1
Parent:     NET-63-0-0-0-0
NetType:    Direct Allocation
NameServer: NS.CAIS.COM
NameServer: NS2.CAIS.COM
Comment:    ADDRESSES WITHIN THIS BLOCK ARE NON-PORTABLE
RegDate:    1999-12-09
Updated:    2004-11-12

OrgAbuseHandle: PAD13-ARIN
OrgAbuseName:   PCCW AUP Department
OrgAbusePhone:  +1-703-621-1637
OrgAbuseEmail:  

Edit: I have written a second Evony article giving an overview and background.

Is Evony Malware?

Evony advert ridiculed by PopCap.

Queen of Evony competition.

  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • N4G
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Slashdot
  • NewsVine
  • Blogosphere News
  • email
  • MySpace
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Fark
  • Netvibes
  • FriendFeed
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • Mixx
  • PDF
  • Ping.fm
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Propeller
  • BlinkList
  • Diigo
  • DZone
  • Faves
  • Simpy
  • Add to favorites

Related stories

  1. More about Evony
  2. Empire Craft, the next Evony?
  3. Evony and Bruceongames

96 comments ↓

#1 Bruce on 07.10.09 at 1:53 pm

Evony – A patchwork of stolen parts.

http://www.arksark.org/blog/2009/07/05/evony-a-patchwork-of-stolen-parts/

#2 Arkenor on 07.10.09 at 4:05 pm

Thanks for the link, Bruce!

It boggles my mind that Google is prepared to carry ads for those scoundrels.

#3 Todd on 07.10.09 at 11:47 pm

So you know what’s funny? I’m reading your post right now, and just to the right of it is a banner ad for Evony.

#4 Bruce on 07.11.09 at 8:07 am

Another article about Evony spamming: http://www.popehat.com/2009/07/10/how-not-to-sell-me-on-using-a-web-product/

#5 Bruce on 07.11.09 at 11:01 am

Evony causing problems with Adsense
http://www.google.com/support/forum/p/AdSense/thread?tid=7c9ef267b8b3c01f&hl=en

#6 Bruce on 07.11.09 at 11:05 am

Evony as a scam: http://www.nfopocalypse.com/index.php/2009/05/13/civony-gold-farmers-go-first-party/

#7 Bruce on 07.11.09 at 11:06 am

More on Evony as a scam: http://erdtirdmans.blogspot.com/2009/05/gems-from-evonycivony-forums.html

This is what is happening: http://bbs.evony.com/showthread.php?t=5280

#8 Bruce on 07.12.09 at 6:54 am

The Chinese behind Evony: http://mu.ranter.net/civony/civony-update-free-game-apparently-funded-by-thousands-of-stupid-world-of-warcraft-players

“……….Turns out that umge.com is a Guangzhou-based company that is developing Civony, some other Flash game called Leuric, and apparently a traditional Windows client MMOG. They’re apparently also associated with WoWMine, an MMOG farmer/gold seller operation that gets bad reviews in MMOG gold seller news sites………….”

#9 Bruce on 07.12.09 at 9:31 am

I found this: “Super Continental LLC just got sued by Microsoft for Click Fraud. Eric Lams owns Super Continental and he owns UMGE LLC which is the developer for Evony.”

#10 John on 07.12.09 at 9:33 am

There’s an evony ad on your blog, stupid. Do something about it.

#11 Bruce on 07.12.09 at 9:41 am

John, I have emailed Google to tell them what is going on and I have posted on the adsense forum that I linked to above. Evony are spamming like crazy just now, they must know that the bubble is about to burst.
But they will be back again with another scam.

#12 Crazy Dave on 07.12.09 at 11:36 am

Isn’t this the game whose advertisement says “I need you my lord” or something like that?

Heh, if I’m going to to spend my time playing an online game, I will choose a decent one that isn’t made by the Chinese.

Nice detective work Bruce. Let’s just hope that Google stops spamming the web with Evony ads upon getting enough concern emails and calls from people.

#13 cab on 07.12.09 at 12:59 pm

can someone please tell me why there is a hot chick as the banner for this game? i dont want to play it but you gotta admit she is hot as!

#14 joe on 07.12.09 at 2:16 pm

ironically, there’s an evony banner on this page for me.

#15 Jim on 07.12.09 at 4:34 pm

Just ad the urls – found on that Adsense link http://www.google.com/support/forum/p/AdSense/thread?tid=7c9ef267b8b3c01f&hl=en – that Evony is using to your competitive ad filter to stop the ads from appearing on this site. Worked for me. Google isn’t going to stop them when they’re making money off them. We’ve been complaining for a long time now but at least we’re not letting them continue to show ads on our websites.

#16 Bruce on 07.12.09 at 4:51 pm

Jim, I have put the following in my Adsense content filter. The problem is that they keep on coming up with new urls. Google might be making money, but will they get paid when the bubble bursts?

evony.com
evonygame.com
evonyhome.com
evonyminiclip.com
evonyonline.com
evonyy8.com
playevony.com
evonyfreeonlinegames.com
evony-game.com
evonygamezer.com
evonymyspace.com
sweetgameonline.com
playnowmelord.com
chooselucky.com

#17 Rich on 07.12.09 at 8:56 pm

even so i think its a good game

#18 Jim on 07.13.09 at 7:13 am

I dont doubt they will continue adding new domains so hopefully the small but growing group of people reporting these new domains will continue. Whether or not either Evony or Google gets paid doesnt concern me since one is enabling the other. It’s right there in plain sight on the Google Adsense forum yet Google takes no steps or responds to the problem. As usual we look for support from each other.

#19 Bruce on 07.13.09 at 2:29 pm

Lots on Evony advertising here: http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/001286.html

#20 Rampand on 07.13.09 at 6:12 pm

Thanks for the links guys. I knew there was something fishy about these flash ads.

#21 S. on 07.14.09 at 4:13 am

Evony is developed and owned by RMT-seller http://www.wowmine.com (this is not an advertisement, it’s the truth). This company earns between $300.000 to $500.000 PER DAY from selling WoW Gold, which enabled them to single-handedly develop their own mmorpg with a CHINESE team.

The CEO of “UGME” (non-existent company!) is Eric Lam. Yes, the same Eric Lam who was sued by Microsoft for nearly a million for ADVERTISEMENT FRAUD just a few weeks ago: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/16/business/media/16adco.html

Everything said in this blog post can be verified by e-mailing me. The truth behind Eric Lam, WoWMine and Evony needs to be exposed for once and for all! (this truth is instantly deleted if mentioned on Evony’s official forums).

#22 Bruce on 07.14.09 at 5:43 am

Good article on the Evony advertising and where the imagery is coming from: http://www.jeffhaines.com/blog/?p=46

#23 Bruce on 07.14.09 at 6:05 am

This article http://artgrafi.com/comment-spam-lewd-advertising-and-stolen-assets-abound-for-evony.html is a great overview of what is going on. With some great links to other good articles around the web going into further details of what is going on here with Evony.

#24 Gabe on 07.14.09 at 12:00 pm

Great to see someone’s doing something about this.

The ads personally pisses me off the most… they are not just misleading or annoying or distasteful…they are a blatant lie. The game does not consist of boobies or “saving you queen” …looks like the game developers thinks that all males are sexually deprived basement dwellers.

#25 Bruce on 07.14.09 at 2:40 pm

Some of the companies, people and websites behind Evony: http://www.wowgoldfacts.com/?p=825

#26 anon on 07.14.09 at 5:47 pm

Why does this new game have the same look and feel?

#27 Bruce on 07.14.09 at 8:53 pm

Here is an email I received today:

hello, A bunch of evony users (myself included) have decided to hold a walkout and will not be using evony until they stop using their unorthodox advertising methods…
I ask that you please help us by making blog posts about this to create publicity. The Evony Team does not want the walkout to have publicity thus our message will be conveyed if you help us…
You can read the walkout announcement on the Evony Users Association group on evony…

#28 Jim on 07.15.09 at 12:41 am

Google has finally decided to look at the problem by escalating the ads to their adwords specialist team as noted in their own response http://www.google.com/support/forum/p/AdSense/thread?tid=7c9ef267b8b3c01f&hl=en

Of course escalating the problem and actually taking action are two different subjects. We’ll see how long it takes. I remember a very similar adwords scam that employed the same technique which affected nearly everyone and that ad campaign is still running. Yes. That was also after it was escalated.

#29 captbasch on 07.15.09 at 5:51 am

The best way to combat this kind of spam abuse is to directly report it to their support center. So we did try to contact one of the Evony admins a few days ago and gave them the spam related links and screenshots. You can read our resentment about their spamming here:
http://www.mmogrindhouse.com/game-news/bizarre/do-you-have-what-it-takes-to-be-the-next-spam-queen/#more-1559

#30 Bruce on 07.15.09 at 6:22 am

Another email:

we have decided last minute to not do a walkout…
but there is much unrest in the evony forums…
the staff don’t get along with the users, one of the best moderators were banned for not much reason (ban should be lifted soon) the off topic section is like a time bomb…
if someone posts the wrong thing mass banning will occur, evony seems to be hanging from a string…
I encourage you to monitor this, i could lead to a good blog post…

#31 Bruce on 07.15.09 at 7:19 am

Excellent quick summary of Evony with good links: http://mu.ranter.net/civony/is-this-really-subliminal#more-1301

#32 Joyce on 07.15.09 at 4:35 pm

My husband is addicted to this game and pays no attention to me at all ever since he started playing it. How do I get him to at least cut down on his playing time? It’s gotten so bad that if I ask him the simplest questions while he’s playing, he snaps at me! WTF!?! He comes home from work and directly turns on his computer and ignores me completely for the entire night. I even have to go to bed alone because he plays so late. HELP!

#33 captbasch on 07.15.09 at 5:48 pm

Re: Joyce
wear your sexiest lingerie and seduce him by saying “Play now, my Lord” and call me in the morning… (JK)

#34 JimH on 07.21.09 at 1:23 pm

I have played this game for a few days and it is fairly enjoyable as “civ” type games go. However, based on the comments above (and my own frugality) I will NOT be buying any game currency. Still, all this raises an interesting question. If a company makes a product that is at least somewhat rewarding is it right to use said product if the some of the company’s business practices are less than proper? After all, most of you are using Windows aren’t you?

#35 Person on 07.22.09 at 9:17 am

They’ve even started stealing advertisements from the True dating service: http://showerbeers.blogspot.com/2009/07/evony-steals-true-advertisements-spams.html

#36 Matthew on 07.22.09 at 10:28 am

They’re constantly advertising on my website http://www.darnkitty.com/, I’m worrying that the advertisements are becoming more and more risque and less and less appropriate for my site!

#37 aj on 07.23.09 at 3:19 am

I think Google should stop displaying their ads….its just everywhere and plain ridiculous!

That chick on their banner must be one of the most recognizable faces on the internet in the past month or so…god damn spammers!

#38 The Raymond SSC Security on 07.25.09 at 4:17 am

Yes after following the “EVONY” thing i agree with eveyone who posted here, EVONY pretty much is runned by 1 person, The funny thing is it get’s 500,000 unique vistors to it’s website http://www.evony.com. Too bad the people who play evony don’t know the facts about the game, The only thing they know it is a game with a hot women as a banner front, also if you ever click on a link banner they all lead to google adsense and all my website now for some reason display EVONY. I think someone like all of us here should start an organization that hates EVONY.

#39 Eric on 07.26.09 at 5:35 am

I started playing and it seems like a decent strategy game but a friend just told me you cannot get past level 10 without pay to play.

I play Ikariam and in that game you don’t get any real advantage when you pay to play except reports on one page for all of your cities. Also, you can queue building to build after current projects. Not really too big an advantage.

#40 amos on 07.29.09 at 1:27 pm

Joyce,your husband is clearly addicted to this game ,you should seek counseling with your husband because this might be bad for your relationship with your husband..forget about talking to your husband on managing his time,because this game requires one to be VERY active to enjoy being at the top,another thing you should fear is your husband dumping a lot of money in the game…the better he quits the game and get his life on track the better it is….i failed most of my subjects by playing these types of games,and i even pour in an amount of RM 500.00 which is a lot of money in malaysia into a similar game,Travian….Other players:please be aware of the fact that these types of games may be exciting but would make your life worse.

#41 Niko on 08.01.09 at 6:09 pm

Can someone suggest a better and similar mmo flash based game. I like Evony, but I’d rather play something without all the bad press.

#42 Bruce on 08.01.09 at 6:15 pm

Runescape.

#43 austin on 08.03.09 at 2:56 am

evony rockes

#44 Rampand on 08.03.09 at 3:59 am

@ Joyce.

The symptoms you have listed are typical of a MMO addict. The bad news is that merely dissuading him from playing evony might prove to be even worse than the situation at hand, because evony is one of the less addictive MMOs out there. Like any addiction, if you want him to stop playing, only a decision from his part will help.

Make him understand how you feel about his playing, and how it may hurt your relationship. Don’t be demanding or try to set limits, or it may just spiral into a pointless control/power struggle. If he just ignores your overture, you’ld be better off seeing a counsellor.

tl;dr
1. Be understanding to him
2. Try talking it over
3. If the above fail, go in for counselling
4. ????
5. PROFIT!!1!1!

#45 KCPTECH on 08.05.09 at 11:33 am

This game rakes in money for the owners of it, period. Its daily revenue is phenomenal.
The really isn’t free if you want to keep what you have after the 7 day no-fire policy. Everything in the game cost game cents. Your Credit card or Pay Pal account will cost you $5 per 50 cents of in-game currency. Items cost between 50 cents to 400 cents, and only last from 24 hours to 7 days. Some people may spend nothing, but eventually lose everything they have to an invasion with those spending real money to buy items.

To do the math, the game collects on average $5 a day from players. Some spend nothing and others spend a lot. At $5 a day, with 5750 players on each continent, and 30 continents per server, and 46 servers in operation, that’s a pretty good scam I think. Yes, almost 36 million dollars a month. The game owned and operated by an actual Gold miner, who realizes he can make much more money this way than having to discover, claim, mine and refine actual gold.

#46 Jim on 08.05.09 at 7:02 pm

Adsense Pro Policy has announced:
Any Evony ads should now point only to evonyonline.com, so having evonyonline.com on your filter list should now effectively block all Evony ads.

To read the entire response from Google:
http://www.google.com/support/forum/p/AdSense/thread?tid=7c9ef267b8b3c01f&hl=en

#47 Hotnoob on 08.09.09 at 8:13 am

yeah, it’s spam, but the only thing that people can actually do about it is stop playing the game, because they arn’t really doing anything illegal… other than their game being mostly copy and paste.

#48 Trevor on 08.14.09 at 7:44 pm

shutup hobknockers evony is a supportive game

#49 John Tulcon on 08.20.09 at 2:38 pm

Do you really get to see pics like the girl in a bra up there. because when I signed up it was super clean and I only signed up to see pic like that.

#50 Caleb on 08.24.09 at 3:38 am

Sexy girl with big tits saying “come play”….Shitty, pointless/time consuming not to mention boring civilization style online game…show me the connection here…And what a shameless way to get horny, bored geeks to play their sub-par strategy “game”. I can’t believe people are giving these greedy pricks real money for game coin…What is wrong with these people?!

#51 TonySmith on 08.24.09 at 2:31 pm

Joyce,

If you’re struggling to get your husband off the computer, wear a low cut dress and say “Art thou coming hither to thy chamber, my lord”?

#52 frichie on 08.24.09 at 4:16 pm

How is this any different to the multitude of facebook games that require u to visit websites in exchange for cresits/coins whatever, and yes you can skip the mission and just pay by credit card/paypal.

I started playing evony on thursday, its been fun so far, and not as time consuming as other games, cos u limited in what u can do (upgrade 1 building at a time etc) so unless you want to watch the poor animation for 5min-1hr, you switch over and do something else,all the while resources accumulate. I havent needed to BUY any coins and wont anyway, you get most stuff through rewards.

BUT I am concerned by the sinister (sounding) developers and whether they are in fact using my bandwidth to do something else behind the scenes. Although the game doesnt seem to be bandwidth intensive, i have noticed a distinct drop in performance when downloading and Evony is running in the back ground. Im gonna do a malware sweep tonight.

#53 J Money on 08.25.09 at 5:04 pm

Stop being pusscakes its a free online game!

I have recently started playing Evony, it is an online multi-player strategy game. At first I was just checking it out to see what all the hype was about. I continued to play because of the atmosphere and online neighborhood. I joined an alliance right away and the quest instructions were very clear and helpful. The combination of these two things gives this game an upper hand on any other game I have played in this category because you get the support of your fellow players and the admin team. The 7 day protection is a great way to build your empire so you dont get rocked by a feuding enemy which is amazing because it makes you be able to get into everything and learn the skills before you gradually go further into the game. I would reccommend this game to anyone who likes strategy games (especially medieval ones) and would also rate it as the best game to just pick up and play for new folks too! The intergration right on the browser makes it available pretty much anywhere anytime.

Come play,

DooHaBucS
Server 30

#54 Tatiana on 08.26.09 at 11:04 am

OK. I don’t care if evony is a cool game or not. Just do not use some chick’s breasts (or some sluts with provocative looks) as your advertisement.

sickening, if this goes on I will sue google.

#55 Reggie on 08.26.09 at 11:09 am

Tatiana, you are a retard. You even use the word “slut” to refer to the women in the advertising. Holy cow, just stick your head in a bucket already, or, maybe, sue yourself! Ha ha!

#56 H on 08.29.09 at 9:40 pm

So the ugly looking bitch has a problem with the slut with provocative looks ha ? Welcome to the 21st Centuary Tatiana !

#57 Patterson on 08.30.09 at 5:52 am

OK, here’s how I see it. It’s run by the Chinese, which a lot of people find worrisome this day and age… it’s run by gold farmers who nobody, but gold buyers, are fond of. That’s a separate issue in and of itself, and not really associated with evony. Evony is a symptom of an overall ‘gold-seller problem’.

The other major issue seems to be their ad campaign practices. While I disagree with spamming and the like, one can hardly blame evony for slapping some pixel-skin on their ads just because people are clicking it. The fact of the matter is that its a great way to get a first look, but if people are looking for some jollies, they won’t have to wait long to find out evony’s not that kinda site, and thus as an ad campaign it has no real staying value. People play the game because they like the game. Aside from this particular site, most seem to just complain about false advertising (just funny, not technically anything criminal about the lack of half-nude women) and how the game is boring (hardly a crime).

Also, my take on the censoring of comments by evony staff: Yeah, sorta lame, until you stop and think that all MMO games function pretty much the same way. Why not hop on the Warcraft boards and start calling for a boycott until they do something about dirty role playing where kids can see it (a legitimate concern for lots of people) and see how long before they remove the thread. Besides, it’s China, a land currently based on government censorship, hardly surprising they’d go that route.

Oh, and as far as the woman with the addicted husband… No one online twists one’s arm for money in this game, although they make it pretty easy to spend. You don’t -have- to spend money to make it big in the game, it just takes more of a time investment. Oh, and speaking of which, the time he’s spending online with this game isn’t playing. The game is specifically designed to be played over large amounts of time. While the first few buildings and upgrades come quickly, the majority of the game is carried out over spans of hours, days, or weeks in which the player can do little more than wait. Same thing goes if they’re big in attacking other players. Eventually you’re pillaged out for a while. If your husband is spending 8 hours a day glued to his screen, he’s not doing anything but watching timers and talking to his online buddies. Evony isn’t the problem, he’s got problems with addiction. If it’s not Evony, it will be something else, and not necessarily a video game. He’s gonna need counseling, I’d wager, but he’s gonna have to want to do it himself.

In short, I think folks make a bigger deal of this game than it is. The people who support them financially and buy game coins are the same people who buy gold in games like WoW, whereas the people who don’t (IF they like evony at all) will play it the ‘hard’ way, because they like the challenge of a good game. If they’re advertising in a way that offends your sensibilities, I hate to say it but ‘Welcome to the Internet, it only goes downhill from here…’ If you’re offended because they advertised ‘bewbies’ and you didn’t get any, grow up. If you’re offended because they’re Chinese, take stock of the items you have in your home that were produced there, or have components that were. If you’re offended because they sell gold, get mad at the buyers who keep them in business and create such a market. If you’re offended because the game is boring, go play something else. Pretty sure that will cover everyone’s contingencies.

#58 Lord Mitovius on 08.30.09 at 6:23 am

i was about to enter the game tonight, when this article came across my view. i hate adds, even thought its known that they support the free part of the game. i just hate them to death.

thank you for preventing me from being dissappointed.

long live Hard copy games.

#59 Blake on 08.31.09 at 10:12 am

I have the I-Evony Client and it did have some kind of malware but not sure cuz my virus protector shut it down and deleted it as soon as i Installed

#60 Patterson on 09.01.09 at 12:28 am

My guess is it was identified as such because it’s designed to access e-mail systems from a third party program. In otherwords, I can use it to send an invite via an aol e-mail account without actually logging into aol to do it.

#61 Lord Duke Nukem on 09.07.09 at 5:36 am

Boy, you people get upset over the most trivial things. Evony hasn’t cost me a dime yet and I have been playing for about a month now. I have two cities on the game and I enjoy it. The bloke that said he hates advertising: have you looked around? Advertising is everywhere. Do you wander around with blinders so you never have to look at a billboard? Do you get all upset when a commercial plays on TV? Perhaps the reason he doesn’t like ads is he lacks the self control not to purchase everything because he saw a clever ad about it. That’s your fault pal, not the ads. Making you part with coin is the purpose of advertising after all.

As far as the litigation aspect of it goes, the United States as well as some of the other industrialized nations are in bad need of tort reform and a loser pays system. Amazon is being sued by a 17 year old high school student over the loss of the book “1984″ removed from his Kindle. The upshot is he couldn’t complete his assignment because the book was no longer on his Kindle. Amazon found out they didn’t have the publishing rights to the text so the removed it to prevent a copyright infringement suit and the got sued by this moron anyway. If we had a loser pays system this 17 year old moron who doesn’t possess the wherewithal to go to a library and check out the print edition of George Orwell’s book “1984″ would be responsible for paying Amazon’s legal fees. That would put an end to much of this type on nonsense. Before you get upset that this would limit the peoples access to civil courts, the simple solution would be bond underwriting the same method that criminals use now to bond out of jail. If they can do it it not a stretch for a bondsman to underwrite the loser pays escrow.

Remember, Evony is a free game that will try to sell you stuff each time you login to play. Whether you buy anything is entirely up to you. Evony isn’t going to charge anyone a fee to play because the would kill the golden goose. There are enough credit card wielding idiots playing the game now. I’m just not one of them.

BTW, I’ve earned 40 credits which is worth 4 game coins by advertising my join link in the same places I found it…on opt-in traffic exchanges. I don’t want to upset our ad hater bloke, you’ll find ads on opt-in traffic exchanges.

#62 viv on 09.08.09 at 11:24 am

I have played evony for few weeks now and it does not have fair play if you build up to high lvl without spending any cash you get wiped out ,My opion is they have in game players to do this to make you spends money to re build game SUCKS……………………..

#63 Bobbeh on 09.09.09 at 2:56 am

Well, all I can say is it looks like Evony sucks ass.

#64 Steve on 09.10.09 at 3:03 am

In game advertising sux. It’s not a matter of “OMG can I resist the temptation to buy”, but more the annoyance factor. I hated the gold spammers on WoW and no doubt would detest the Evony scams / spammers even more.

Secondly, be very very wary of installing their software. If you’ve heard of the “Storm worm” then you’ll know what I mean. China has a bad reputation for malware and you might just get a permanent infection to be implemented by the perpetrator at an indeterminate time in the future. Oh and if you think your current virus scanners / malware programs will detect it, you may be mistaken. “Storm” can be detected on individual computers only. Try to remove it and the program attacks. It can’t be detected across a broad range of computers because it modifies its own code every time it transmutes. Imagine what they could download to your computer upon install ….
And hey maybe that’s not their intention, but they sure do seem like a sneaky company to me.

Thirdly, who the hell wants a fun game to suddenly turn bad, after you’ve dedicated hundreds of hours to it, by the bots attacking your towns (and all your alliance too) just because you guys decided not to pay real cash for improvements? Maybe they weren’t bots, but how would you know? Obviously they could generate messages like F@#$ you loser (or whatever).

Hey your alliance better get these guys, lets spend some real dollars and kick butt!!!
Easy way to sucker new buyers into their cash economy …..

Fourthly, yeah I’ve done a fair bit of reading into this game (including their forums). Sounds quite fun in some ways, but the battle mechanics need a serious revamp.
What army in history has ever won that focuses so strongly on catapults and archers (to the point of needing no skirmishers)?

Fifthly, big tits / hot chick (no I didn’t say filthy, please learn to read lol), forget about her, that’s just advertising. If you buy a womens magazine you’ll find much the same story. Come to think of it, if you buy a mens magazine same again. Check out the TV, billboards, utube, mailbox paraphernalia, taxi cabs, blimps and yes even National Geographic. Just a fact of life. If you get suckered in by it then perhaps you’ll learn for the next time when you’re bombarded by sexy advertising.

#65 WT on 09.10.09 at 12:04 pm

A priceless advice for anyone who considers playing Evony: first, register in their forums and read carefully, specifically the Bug section. You will see what people experience for months: the American company who is behind the project could not care less about any complaints people report. People write, they lose real money in the game, experience loss of access for days following upgrades, bugs that leave they behind in the game – I repeat, they report they lose the real money they put in the game – but they never get any replies from the service. In the forum, players who report these issues get banned (go see it with your own eyes, it is all visible), and the topics get closed by admins without a reason.
According to me, these guys have no future.

#66 Ryan on 09.14.09 at 6:58 am

Hey Bruce,
if you have ever played Age of Empires II (Cheap game now, it is ten years old!) you will see the perspective and graphics are just stolen from it.

#67 Salsa on 09.14.09 at 4:51 pm

Graphics stolen – I don’t care.
Copyright infringed – I don’t care.
Adds sexist – so are >50% of all adds I see everywhere.
Adds stolen – I don’t care.
System copied, ripped off – I don’t care.

Now… costs money – no it doesn’t. You can do everything in the game without paying a single cent/penny/etc. If you choose to spend money on “a game” then it’s your stupidity if you don’t want to.

What don’t I like about Evony.
There is no contact or admin support, at all. Zero, absolutely nothing. I can’t post on the forum. My existing account is not banned but I can’t login. When I ask for password reminder – nothing. When I contact via bugreport – nothing. If I try to create a new account – can’t. I have no way to contact Evony for any legitimate reason. But, meh, it’s free, so no one has any right to complain – though I know they will anyway.

So overall, if it seems to be too good to be true – it probably is. “Free” stuff on the internet is >95% not free. Money doesn’t grow on trees and all that. The only way I know to get good stuff free is download it illegally. There are a few exceptions, but that’s the general rule. So Evony isn’t any different from all the other gumph on the internet – but that doesn’t stop anyone does it.

If it’s that bad, throw away your computer. Get a life. Go rockclimbing or travel. But if you complain, you’re wasting more time than you waste playing MMOs. As far as I can see, it’s just another form of attention seeking. Nobodies forcing you – are they?

#68 louis on 09.15.09 at 3:04 am

i dont understand, evony is a great game like age of empires or empire earth (sort of) but why Bruce Everiss are u critizizing the game like that? maybe some people dont like the game but its really dumb to post this and send it to evony. all i can say bruce is good luck with the lawsuit

#69 hebeiren on 09.16.09 at 8:27 am

Sigh.. I’m Chinese and I could tell it was a Chinese game just by looking at the style of advertising. Ironically most Chinese people would probably recognize it as a money-grubbing scam (there’s 100 times more “games” like this in China), and avoid it right away. You westerners need to smarten up, because I bet this kind of thing will be commonplace in the future, and not just from China either.

Unfortunately, even the internet is not immune to shanzhai garbage…

#70 SeanB on 09.16.09 at 5:53 pm

Evony, which used to be Civony, is changing it’s name again. Now it’s Kingory. Exact same game yet again, same stupid advertising tactics, just a new name.

#71 galager on 09.20.09 at 7:04 am

When you see the ads, click on them and then close the browser.

You will make money for the site the shows the ad.

The real win is that EVONY will have to pay for all those clicks! When they run out of money for ads, the ads will stop.

So, please click on all the ads you see! this will get them gone!

#72 JohnB on 09.25.09 at 3:14 am

I played this game for about 2 months and did not miss one day. It destroys you to the point that you worry about sleeping in case someone attacks you and 2 months worth of work is blown. I never paid a cent to play this game and got into the top 300 on the server through hard work. But playing before, during and after work each day and 12-15 hours a day on weekends, neglecting my wife and child tooks its toll. After a total commitment to the game I walked away after appologising to my alliance members and plan not to return. This is a single persons game because you have to leave everything else behind to stay at the top. Good game, I agree, but nerve and relationship destroying

#73 Cody B. on 09.25.09 at 5:49 pm

I, too was planning on blogging about the similarities between Civ 3 and 4 and the ludicrous ad campaign, but I think I will most likely link to your blog since you have pretty much covered the gamut, so to speak. Great job as always Mr. Everiss. Keep up the HONEST GOOD WORK!!!!! The world needs more people like you!

#74 Chad on 09.28.09 at 7:52 pm

OMG Boobs on the internet!!!!!

NOOOO, What has this world come too!!!!

#75 BudWeiser on 10.01.09 at 2:35 pm

this game needs to be flushed down the toilet.

#76 Lance on 10.02.09 at 1:43 pm

The game blows and the advertisement is just a hook it’s not worth the time. you might as well go out and get a good game. I played it for maybe 20 minutes and was like wow this is no fun what so ever it’s nothing to get excited over unless your lonely and just want to stair at the advertisements.

#77 LLReich on 10.04.09 at 4:29 pm

…. think above would b bad enough …. check out evony forum re: hundreds, if not thousands of complaints made by paying customers of offer termed 250c for $5! Sheeish! What a disappointment.

#78 LLReich on 10.04.09 at 5:05 pm

p.s. don’t believe me? take a look:

http://bbs.evony.com/showthread.php?t=59914

http://bbs.evony.com/showthread.php?t=58818

this is just example of TWO thread compliants – there are numerous others.

#79 L.J on 10.05.09 at 3:04 am

DO NOT PLAY THIS GAME!!!!
I figured I give it a shoot and check it out.I have never played a game like this before. I learned my lesson in this game you buy coins to purchase items to use and play this game. I had items, coins and other thing go missing into thin air over night!!!?? Other items just dont work and cause problems playing the game!! I spent over $300 usd on this game when I noticed that ..ha I couldnt have use this and that, So I started watching the game more carefully when I noticed the problems. I have sent 10-15 emails to everyone I could to figure out a way to fix this problems. All I get back is the same reply email telling me how to log in onto the server??? Thats not the problem Im having! They use and hide behind Paypay as a way of payment leaving you feel safe cause after all “paypal is the safest way to pay online” NOT!! paypal will not help you and they know that they are other people having this same problem with them but dont do anything about it.Its something that the buyer protection doesnt cover!

#80 Gaming Reviews on 10.06.09 at 3:50 am

lol yeah, there is an evony ad right next to the article. I found it ironic. But anyways, I’ll admit I played this game for about 2 days. Then it came down to the point that it took so long to do anything and I finally decided to quit playing this garbage due to they try to get you to pay. PAY!?!? For what? Absolutely nothing. It’s a waste of space and it kinda confuses me too as to why G is letting them run ads. I guess it all comes down to the Benjamins….

#81 Evonyscam on 10.07.09 at 12:03 am

Hey, I am spreading the news my friend. Check my blog at http://evonyscam.wordpress.com/

Keep up the good work Bruce, don’t give up.

#82 Rudeawakening on 10.08.09 at 2:25 am

this game is rubish u have no control what so ever, all mmo are turning into crap.. and scams, they draw u with the social aspect then really ur just interacting with other losers (to the game ofcourse) :P

why spend 300-500$ on this game while u can get a console or another game which u have full controll over.. want social aspect ? making a website finding local people with same interest to share your gaming needs and interact with real people… in general all MMO are scams… money makes company company needs to find ways to make money , and best money making tool is MMO games :P simple really..

#83 vaughan on 10.09.09 at 9:38 pm

hey bruce i went to register on evony and it said my email address was been used by another emporer. how do i stop this so i can keep well away from evony?

#84 A on 10.11.09 at 2:03 pm

I’m tired seeing Evony’s shit adverts everywhere. I’m installing adblock now.

#85 lulu on 10.12.09 at 12:43 am

Bruce … found this little tidbit on Evony’s Forum … it’s a billing claim from money brokers … check out the Regan Mechantile (Hong Kong) – I think HONG KONG IS in CHINA … last time I looked … amazing how Evony has claimed they r not China based corp but billing is coming from HONG KONG …. (perhaps a GLITCH??!!??) … just thought is was interesting …. copied directly from the evony forum ….

TRANSACTION CONFIRMATION

You have successfully made a payment to Regan Mercantile(Hong Kong) Limited using your credit/debit card (VISA, xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx) on XX XXX 2009.

The amount of USD 50.00 has successfully been debited from your credit/debit card.

This charge will appear on your card statement as a debit by: MB*Moneybookers.com

Sincerest regards,

Moneybookers

*******************************

Moneybookers Ltd., London, Registered in England and Wales no 4260907.
Registered office: Welken House, 10-11 Charterhouse Square, London, EC1M 6EH, United Kingdom.
Authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority of the United Kingdom (FSA).

#86 Daveo.s15 on 10.15.09 at 4:49 am

Well I definately got a shit load of adgen trojans and different things etc by logging on to evony with my virus protection turned off.. 88 all up I had.. Michael Jackson songs would start playing then I could hear commercials coming out of my speakers but nothing on the screen.. also my e-mail address I use for evony is now constantly spammed every day wif crap.. I mean 100 email perday.. very annoying searching for real mail inbetween all the junk..

#87 aussie on 10.17.09 at 3:23 pm

I love the game (true some people in the chats are simple jerks, but what can you do?).
But, in regards to Bruce’s lawsuit and being Australian myself, that after reading some posts I felt compelled to make my own comments on EvonyMasters.com…….basically no so much as supportive of Bruce, but clearly on his side of the fence….and also clearly defendingthe Australian Courts – I am sure Evony will be fined minimum by courts if they proceed. This is due to the fact that I do know something of Corporate law and have been involved in IT (alot in security) for some time (over 10yrs). I am totally convinced that evony is ‘walking the plank’ as I put it in regards to their vilification of a not-for-profit blogger.

Strangely enough – 2 mins after I posted that comment, The servers were upgraded and I can no longer log into my accounts. I fully suspect that my IP address may now have been blocked by them. We will see if that is the case….but its also true that everytime you complain about the many, many bugs in the programming you get no response except how to logon. Their lack of respect for the gaming community will ultimately be their downfall. Unfortunately…..

#88 Antje on 10.19.09 at 3:59 pm

I’ve been wondering whether it was a Nigerian scam after all.

#89 me on 10.31.09 at 4:41 am

evony is a great game and sometimes i stay awake right through the night as i am while writing this.It is a great game but someone needs to make something like it that doesn’t involve paying for cents as it gives some an unfair advantage.

#90 MissGin on 11.05.09 at 10:14 pm

Evony is the best!! but there are tons of ppl who are there just cuz they clicked on a add that has nothing to do with the game… and they end up not playing very long…

#91 kirk on 11.08.09 at 9:08 pm

i have played evony for almost 2 months now and while i think its a decent game (in some reguards) i dispise the constant encuragement to spend money on the game.
i did spend some money on it however the conversion is really pethetic compared to games like last chaos or perfect world (played both those for 7 months at a time) with evony its $1 = 10 cents with last chaos $1 = 100 AP with perfect world its $1 = 1 gold if i remember the currency right however perfect world may sound like it is a rip the value is pretty decent considering its got 2 forms of currency
in my time playing evony i have noticed several things that concerned me like it being nearly impossbale to progress with cities then the requiering items to make lv 10 buildings simplistic battle mechanics without visuals
overall i find runescape funner and a better value (btw if theres a reveiw on runescape id like to read it)

#92 Dani on 11.09.09 at 3:30 pm

I hate Evony because it tkes time away from my relationship. I think there should be more Computer addicts anonomys groups out there for people who spend more than 5 hrs leisure time with the computer than with their spouses.

#93 Emily on 11.11.09 at 9:27 pm

theres 2 other games so far thats just exactly like evony its http://www.napwar.com n killgory.com not sure if i spelled the last one right but their both almost exactly like evony just goes buy a different name n seems like better graphics to em then evony has

#94 Sara Fleming on 11.15.09 at 6:07 am

I used to be a player on the game untell there was a large amount of racism. A player actualy named himself Hitler (guess what his allience name was). After weeks of complaing he was finaly gone. One of the players on my alliance was getting racist letters from members of a different alliance. Some how they found out she is from Vietnam. Even though we complained, and she sent the letters to the creaters nothing happened. I found out from a person in another alliance that that alliance spends a lot of money on the game. Since they care more about people who spend money on their game and not the other players. I just cann’t play.

#95 Neighbour on 11.18.09 at 10:05 am

I don’t care. You’d swear someone stole your souls the way you all complain. IT IS JUST A USELESS GAME. If you don’t like it, play something else.

If your offended: BIG DEAL! No one cares. The world will always offend your principles, so get over it.

Don’t be schmuck – no one ever spends real currency on low quality nonsense – so DON’T. Spend your money on the people in your life or something. If you do spend it, then you asked for it. How can anyone in this day and age actually trust the internet?

It’s hilarious how some of the men complain about the false adds. Lol. Get over yourselves.

#96 Smokie on 11.20.09 at 5:25 pm

Being said and done…I only came to interest when I googled ‘evony’ and wanted to see a gameplay video or screenshots today. I’ve seen the ads with the hot chicks in them for awhile now, but if your like me, that ad wouldnt faze you a bit. Today marketing and promoting is done in such tasteless ways that you ‘just have to accept it’ for face value. Personally Im more interested in the actual product then what ‘they’ use to sell it/how they sell it. Sure the ad is….’off topic’ if you will, but damn people ITS JUST AN AD…ITS JUST A GAME. If it offends you, ignore it. Plain and simple. If you really want to complain about something then why not bitch at the ‘women’s magazine’ developers. You look on the cover of ANY womens magazine and what do you see? You see a super model, looking all hot wearing skimpy ass clothing and what else do you see on the cover ‘How to have 21 days of scorching hot SEX’, ‘How to please any man’, ‘How to have better sex’, ‘How to turn up your sexlife’ etc etc etc. Which in turn – turns and manipulates all these young girls minds into turning and trying to be someone they really are not….or how about how America is messing up this world and how 9-11 was a lie and set up? or how about ranting for equal rights? There’s alot more messed up problems in this world and on the net…than a simple hot girl posing for a online game! I wish that people put this much effort into real problem solving.

Leave a comment